Top Groomsmen Gifts 2025: Personalized Favor Sets They’ll Actually Use
If you're looking for ways to say thank you to your groomsmen, the most meaningful groomsmen gifts are not just traditions; they are a way to show appreciation. In 2025, the best groomsmen gifts are personal, practical, and built to last; the kind they’ll reach for long after the champagne toast.
We all know the power of memories. As for us, at St Johns Bay Rum, our grooming essentials have always reflected the roots of craftsmanship and tradition. All of our products are hand-blended in small batches and are never just grooming products but are legacy-forward rituals.
We believe a great gift isn’t just a product; it’s a ritual he’ll look forward to every morning. If you want to find a truly personal way to say thank you and appreciate the groomsmen, this blog has got you covered.
Why Personalized Groomsmen Gifts Matter
Your groomsmen have witnessed the joy, the coordination, the bachelor party, and of course, the last-minute tux crisis. A basic bottle opener will not suffice. You require something that shows you understand and appreciate their efforts. More importantly, personalized groomsmen gifts create a memory. For example, a branded fragrance or a custom razor kit becomes a piece of their daily routine and a souvenir they will appreciate.
Personalized gifts for groomsmen demonstrate you have considered their personalities and tastes. Gifts that say, "thanks for being beside me," can seem meaningful, memorable, and functional. According to Healthline, recipients of thoughtful gifts make emotional connections and feel wellness impacts that outweigh and last much longer than the gift. When you pair that intention with the enduring quality of handcrafted grooming tools, your gift becomes an experience.
A few examples of personalization could be initialing a fine aftershave bottle or engraving a grooming kit. These items are not unique, but quality products used daily, such as our Bay Rum Aftershave.
Top Groomsmen Gifts for 2025: What’s Trending
The best groomsmen gifts of 2025 strike a balance between luxury and function. This year, we’re seeing a shift toward:
- Eco-friendly gifts that are sustainably sourced and built to last
- Tech gadgets that simplify everyday routines
- Luxury grooming sets with signature scents and premium tools
- Custom whiskey accessories with engraved glassware or decanters
But the biggest trend of all? Personalization. A well-chosen gift becomes unforgettable when it includes your groomsmen’s initials, a shared memory, or even a custom message.
Our Grooming Gift Set is built for this trend. Bay Rum cologne, Bay Rum aftershave, and premium grooming products cover the bases. It's bold, practical, and definitely personal.
Build-Your-Own: The Personalized Grooming Gift Set
Create a kit that fits each man’s style. Start with a core scent, then add supporting staples so it feels custom, not off-the-shelf.
Choose a core scent:
-
Bay Rum – warm clove and spice; classic, confident.
-
Vetiver – earthy, composed; quietly powerful.
-
No. 77 – bright citrus with herbal lift; easygoing and modern.
-
West Indian Lime – crisp, sun-lit freshness; warm-weather favorite.
Add the essentials:
-
Aftershave (pairs with the core) for a cooling, bracing finish.
-
Soap-on-a-Rope that dries fast and travels clean.
-
Aluminum-free deodorant to stay fresh without harsh extras.
Personalize the details:
-
Monogram the Dopp kit or add a custom note.
-
Include a “how to wear your scent” card with spray count and pairing tips.
-
Match each man’s scent to personality (bold tones like West Indian Lime for the outspoken man, and subtle tones of Bay Rum for the quietly powerful one).
Fool-Proof Personalized Gift Ideas That They'll Actually Use
Here are three ideas that focus on function, but also bring an element of luxury and personalization to the day:
Luxury Grooming Set with Personalized Engraving
A luxury grooming set is never a dull gift with St Johns products. Start with our Bay Rum Aftershave, which is a Caribbean classic made with spicy clove, eucalyptus, and warm notes. Add a classic safety razor, with engraved initials for each groomsman.
Add a to-go dopp kit, and a fragrance from our collection to complete the package. The end result is a bold, bracing, and timeless gift.
Perfect for : Daily routine, business travel, special occasions
Effect : Personalized luxury with a custom scent
Custom Cufflinks & Luxury Shaving Kit
For the sartorially inclined, pair engraved cufflinks with a classic shaving kit. Badger-hair shaving brush, weighted razors, and exclusive batch aftershaves are all included in this combination.
Pair with our Grooming Gift Set to add some signature scent & sensory depth. The combination of modern utility and nostalgia makes this a unique gift for any groomsman.
Perfect for : Black tie events, professional engagements
Effect : Rugged, sophisticated, ambiguously classy
Personalized Whiskey Glasses and Barware
Raise a glass to friendship with engraved whiskey tumblers and bar accessories. Complement this classic gift with a scent that lingers long after the last pour. Our Bay Rum cologne, with its spicy depth and masculine notes, is the perfect finishing touch.
Looking for inspiration? Check out this Men’s Health guide to whiskey accessories.
Perfect for : Home bars, game nights, late-night toasts
Effect : Masculine touch with a lasting impression
Creating a Memorable Thank-You for Your Groomsmen
Excellent gifts for groomsmen do not have to be over the top or fancy. They just need to feel personal, practical, and purposeful.
In 2025, the best gifts are gifts based on sentiment that speak more than just "thanks." The best gifts say, "You are a great friend. You made this journey unforgettable."
With our handmade grooming essentials, you can give a gift that has tradition, bold scent, and personalization all in one gift. Your gift, whether it is a curated grooming set or a single signature grooming product, will become part of a ritual that will be appreciated for many years to come.
Check out our full collection of iconic grooming products. Here’s to timeless tradition, refined elegance, and gifts that last.
